LEVELED READER SETS AT THE LIBRARY

In my last post, I evaluated several Level 1 Leveled Readers that I found at the public library.  I also borrowed several leveled reader sets.  I like the “set” concept because if you find a publisher you like at your child’s reading level, it makes sense to check out many books at this level.  A set makes decision-making easy.

All three leveled reader sets I share below are for beginning readers.  I would estimate all the books in the sets are between level D and F (Guided Reading Level).

Brand New Readers (Green Set) by Candlewick Press

brand new readersThis is my favorite of the three leveled reader sets.  There are 10 books in each of the sets.  The images below are from the book Puddles.  Pages 3 and 4 are similar to pages 1 and 2: Mouse jumps in a puddle.  Mouse gets his pants wet.  Your child will be successful because the text is repetitive and therefore predictable.  The text is humorous, and the illustrations are engaging.

brand new readers ex 1

Page 2

brand new readers ex 2

Page 1

I Love Reading Phonics by TickTock an imprint of Octopus Publishing Group

I also like the I Love Reading Phonics set.  There are 8 books in this set, which is called Level 1.  There are 6 Levels in the series.   The texts are a little more difficult than the texts in the Brand New Readers set.  There is less repetition, but phonics is the focus, so words are phonetically-regular (aka decodable).  Each book in the series has a different phonics focus.  The book shown below on the right, Bret and Grandma’s Trip!, features consonant-consonant-vowel-consonant (or beginning consonant blends) words, such as Bret, spot, crab and trap.  The illustrations are vivid, but the language feels a little forced, as is typical in phonics-controlled texts.  Other books in Level 1 focus on two-syllable words and double consonant endings, such as -ss and -ll.

i love reading phonics

i love reading phonics ex 1

Example pages

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

BOB Books (Sight Words Kindergarten) by Scholastic

I was not impressed with this series.  I do not think it is a great fit for most beginning readers.  The text is highly controlled.  Almost all the words are either sight words or consonant-vowel-consonant (CVC) words.  This aspect paired with the bare-bones illustrations will not attract young readers.  I think this series is a good fit if the reader is struggling and needs texts to be extremely decodable in order to find success.  The texts could also be a good way to assess whether your child can accurately decode CVC words.  I do not think that the BOB Books make for enjoyable daily reading practice.

bob booksbob books example 1

FINDING LEVELED READERS AT THE LIBRARY

My family travels a lot: for my husband’s work, to visit family and friends and to rock climb.  One of first stops after reaching our destination is the library.  We check out some books, a video or two, and generally see what else is available – weekly story hour, toys/games/puzzles that can be checked out, movie night.  And the reading specialist in me always wanders over to the early reader section to see which leveled readers the library has.

Two Reasons I Get Psyched when I see Leveled Readers at the Library
  1. It is beneficial when the public library makes available literacy resources comparable to those used by the school systems.  It makes sense for parents and family to be able to find books that will support their children’s literacy growth at the library.  Yes, picture books are a wonderful resource too, and should be used for read alouds daily, but they are not the best resource for emergent and beginning readers to develop independent literacy skills.
  2. I love FREE things!  I encourage parents to obtain leveled readers, but they are expensive and difficult to purchase from the publishers for home use.  When parents can find leveled readers at the library, the problem is solved!
Why Leveled Readers at the Library are not Perfect
  1. Libraries rarely purchase leveled readers from the same publishers that schools do.  Why? I do not know.  Possibly the big-name school publishers, such as Hameray, Heinemann and the Wright Group at McGraw Hill, are too expensive?
  2. Libraries rarely label the books with common leveling systems, such as Fountas-Pinnell Guided Reading, Reading Recovery or DRA.  Therefore, it is difficult for parents to identify which leveled readers at the library at a good match for their children.
  3. Leveled readers at the library often are labeled with general and ambiguous terms, such as Level 1, Stage 1 or Beginning Reading.  Level 1 and Stage 1 sound like the earliest stages of literacy development and consequently they should have the easiest books, like A-D in the Guided Reading system.  Look at the samples of Level 1, Stage 1 or Beginning Reading books I found at the library during my most recent trip.
 I Found the Following Leveled Readers at the Library

1) A New Friend by Penguin Young Readers (Level 1), 2) Pizza Party! by Scholastic Hello Reader! (Level 1), 3) The Gym Day Winner by Scholastic Reader (Level 1), Elmo Says Achoo! by Step into Reading (Step 1), 5) Penny and her Marble by I Can Read! (Beginning Reading 1) and 6) Animals in Winter by Read and Find Out Science (Stage 1)

I will highlight and give my opinion on the comparability of the “leveling” of some of the abovementioned books.

A New Friend by Penguin Young Readers (Level 1), Guided Reading Level: C

Yes!!! This is what I was looking for in a Level 1 book! On the back cover, level 1 is identified as Guided Reading Level A-D.  This particular book is level C.  Level 1 is for the “emergent reader.”  As you can see if the sample text below, the text includes simple vocabulary, word repetition and very short sentences.  This is the only leveled reader out of the six I found that has a true level from a recognized leveling system.  Go see if your library has the Penguin Young Readers series.  The levels range from 1-4.  I highly recommend this series.

penguin young reader level 1

penguin example

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Pizza Party! by Scholastic’s Hello Reader! (Level 1), Guided Reading Level: F

The Gym Day Winner by Scholastic Reader (Level 1), Guided Reading Level: H

Both of these early reader series are published by Scholastic.  Pizza Party‘s text is similar to A New Dog in that the sentences are short and there is word repetition, but Pizza Party‘s vocabulary is more advanced.  However, the illustrations are very descriptive in Pizza Party so it would be relatively easy to simply look at the illustrations instead of using visual cues (aka sounding it out) to read the words.  The Gym Day Winner features two-syllable words and words with advanced vowel patterns like throw and guard.  Plus, the sentences are much longer.  You really need to have a fair amount of reading strategies to be successful with The Gym Day Winner.  Both of these books are good for readers at the mid- to late-first grade level.

hello reader example

Notice the rhyming pattern in Pizza Party!

scholastic reader example

Longer words and longer sentences make The Gym Day Winner considerably more difficult than A New Day.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Elmo Says Achoo! by Step into Reading (Step 1), Guided Reading Level: G-H (my estimation)

Like The Gym Day Winner, Elmo Says Achoo! features longer sentences and words with more advanced vowel patterns.

Penny and Her Marble by I Can Read! (Beginning Reading 1), Guided Reading Level: J

As you can see, Penny and Her Marble features a lot more text on each page.  It is even a chapter book!  Guided Reading Level J is considering beginning of second grade … a huge difference from A New Friend (level C).  And both books are Level 1 in their series!  But here is the catch.  On the back cover of Penny and her Marble, there is a description of the book levels.  There is actually a level easier than level 1; it is called My First, and it is described as “ideal for emergent readers.”  Okay, hopefully that is where you can find level A-D books.

i can read beginning reader 1i can read example

 

 

 

 

 

Animals in Winter by Read and Find Out Science (Stage 1), Guided Reading Level: K

This book has a comparable book level to Penny and Her Marble, but the non-fiction text has more content specific vocabulary words with which a young reader is likely to be unfamiliar: monarch, pika, hibernate and predator.  However, as I read the back cover more carefully, it became clear that the Stage 1 Level applies to its Science content, not its reading level.  Oops.

In summary

These days, public libraries have more and more leveled readers, but they are not usually leveled by the same system that your child’s school uses. As a parent, in order to select appropriate books for your child, you will need to be versed in how to determine the level of a text.  Three excellent resources come to mind for determining the level of a text:

  1. Scholastic’s Book Wizard – This website, which is now mobile, has cataloged tens of thousands of books’ reading levels.  Simply enter the book’s title and learn its level.  Unfortunately, not all books are cataloged.
  2. Read Sachem, New York school district’s language arts department’s Text Level Indicators article.  The article provides both a description and example of each text level (A-Z). 
  3. Ask the librarian.

Parents: Does your public library have leveled readers available?  What series or titles do you like best?

 

HOW TO PREVIEW A TEXT

Emergent and beginning readers need a lot of support during reading to be successful.  Your primary goal when working with your child is to model the behaviors of good readers.  Therefore, before reading a text, you preview it to get the brain warmed up.  Our youngest readers really benefit from the introduction of concepts and vocabulary terms because they do not have a lot of word attack strategies to read accurately on their own.

You may want to read by post, How to Cue a Beginning Reader?, for more information about meaning, structure and visual cues.  This post will certainly help you to find effective language for previewing a text.

Steps to PREPARE to Preview a Text
  1. Before you preview a text with your child, read it yourself.
  2. Sum up what it is about in one sentence.
  3. If the text is a narrative, or story, ask yourself, is you child familiar with this scenario?  If the text is about a trip to the zoo, has your child been to the zoo?  Will he have any real-life reference points for comprehending the text?  If the text is expository, or non-fiction, what does your child already know about this topic?  If the content is unfamiliar, you will have to be more thorough during your preview.
  4. Identify key vocabulary terms that are integral to the theme of the book.  They may be used multiple times throughout the text.
  5. Identify any words that your child will have difficulty reading, either because their meaning is unfamiliar to him or because they are difficulty to decode.
Let’s see how you could Preview a Text with the book Edna Bakes Cookies.

1.  Read the title of the text to your child.  The title is Edna Bakes Cookies.  Edna is the elephant.  That’s an unusual name, but both Edna and elephant start with the sound /e/.  What kind of cookies do you like to bake?  Do you remember what ingredients we use?  What do you think the book will be about?  Here is where you can share your one-sentence summary of the book.

preview a text 1

2.  Do a “walk through” of each page.  This is when you can address key vocabulary words and difficult-to-decode words.  What is Edna doing on this page?  If he does not know, provide more cues.  Edna is putting in the first ingredient.  Look at the illustration.  What ingredient is that?  If needed, remember we talked about the ingredients you use to make a cake?  Sugar, flour and …?  Yes, butter!  Notice how the word “butter” starts with the letter b.  What sound does b make?  Yes, /b/.  Where does Edna put the butter?  Yes, in the bowl.  See how you are continually cuing in ways that draw your child’s attention to key words in the text.

Preview a Text 2

3.  Do you remember the main character’s name?  If not, provide the elephant’s name.  With every page, keep asking your child what the elephant’s name is.  Edna is a difficult to remember and difficult to decode word so he will need as much exposure as possible to recall the name when it is his time to read.  It looks like Edna is still adding ingredients to the bowl.  What ingredient does that look like?  It does not make sense to cue your child to the beginning letter of sugar, s, because the s in sugar is irregular and sounds like /sh/.  It is unlikely that a beginning reader will be able to use visual cues to decode this word.  However, the next ingredient is flour and directing your child’s attention to the first letter in flour, f, may help him to decode the word.  So we already have butter and sugar for ingredients.  The next ingredient begins with a f.  What sound does an f make?  Which ingredient begins with the sound /f/?  Yes, flour!  Great job.  Can you find the word “bowl” in this sentence?  If the child cannot, cue him to the beginning letter/sound in “bowl.”  What sound does bowl begin with?  Yes, /b/.  Do you see a word in this sentence that begins with the sound /b/?  Child points to the word “bowl.”  Excellent, let’s read the entire sentence together.  Read She puts flour in the ________, and see if your child can supply the word “bowl.”  You can also direct his attention to the word “bowl” in the previous sentence.  Or you can ask him to find the word “bowl” or read the entire sentence.

Preview a Text 3

4.  What is Edna doing with the batter?  If child does not know, say, Look she is using a spoon.  What is she doing to the batter?  Yes, Edna stirs the batter.  Ooh, yummy.  Look at the next page.  What is she doing with the batter now?  Yes, she is tasting.  Can you find the word “taste” in the sentence?  How did you know that word was “taste?”  Do you like tasting the batter when you bake cookies?  You are making a connection to real life experience, which will help your child to better recall the events in the book because they relate to his life.  Do you remember the elephant’s name?

preview a text 4

5.  What is Edna doing here?  Yes, eating “more” batter.  Please find the words “more” and “batter” for me.  Why do you think the word “more” is capitalized?  Yes, because she ate more (in a loud voice)!  Try reading the entire sentence.  Now look at the next page.  What is the elephant doing?  Try to read the sentence.  If you do not know a word, look at the first letter.  

Preview a Text 5

6.  Okay, I have to ask ONE MORE time!  What is the elephant’s name?  Look at the bowl!  Where is the batter?  How did it disappear?  Yes, Edna ate it all.  She ate more and more until it was all gone: No more batter!  Point to the word “more.”  Great!  Go back two pages, do you see the word “more” there, too?  “More” contains an -or vowel pattern, which is more advanced and likely unfamiliar to your child.  Consequently, when your child is reading the text himself, cuing him to “sound out the word” when he comes to “more” is not very helpful.  If he gets stuck, cue with a structure cue, like What word fits in that sentence?  Or you can read the sentence to him with a “blank” for the word “more,” and ask what sounds right in the blank?  

Preview a Text 6

When you preview a text, use the words in the text as much as possible so that your child hears the vocabulary repeatedly.  Now you are ready to read the book by yourself.  You know so many of the words from previewing the text!  Let’s start with the cover.

Prior knowledge (or familiarity with the text’s content) predicts comprehension better than a child’s actual reading ability (Leslie & Caldwell, 2001).  In other words, it is much easier to comprehend a text when the content is familiar to the reader.  Conversely, it is much harder to comprehend a text when the content is new.  Even better an exceptional reader cannot override the fact that the content is unfamiliar.

When you preview a text, the beginning reader becomes familiar with the content.  Yes, it may feel like you are “doing all the work” for him, but he needs all support he can get to be successful at this stage of literacy.

Leslie, L. & Caldwell, J. (2001).  Qualitative Reading Inventory-3.  Addison Wesley Longman: New York.

ORAL READING FLUENCY CHART – HOW FAST SHOULD MY CHILD BE READING?

Read Naturally shares Hasbrouck-Tindal’s Table of Oral Reading Fluency Norms.  This Oral Reading Fluency Chart allows you to compare your child’s oral reading rate to his peers.

A few pieces of information will help you to understand the data:

  1. The Hasbrouck-Tindal oral reading fluency chart uses WCPM (Words Correct Per Minute) as a measure.  In my post, Timed Repeated Reading, I use WPM (Words Per Minute) to mean the same thing.
  2. The second column in the oral reading fluency chart is Percentile.  They list 90, 75, 50, 25 and 10 percentiles.  A percentile is not a percentage.  A percentile is based on a peer group of 100.  90%ile (percentile) means the given child performs better than 90 of his peers.  (It does not mean that he answered 90% of the questions correctly.)  9 of his peers perform better than him.  Another way to express this is that the child is in the top 10% of his peer group.  50%ile means the given child performs better than 50 of his peers.  49 of his peers perform better than him.  A child performing at the 50%ile for a given skill is perfectly average; he is smack in the middle.  25%ile to 75%ile is considered to be in the average range.
  3. The third, fourth and fifth columns in the oral reading fluency chart compares WCPM from the Fall, Winter and Spring of a given school year.  You can observe the typical growth over the course of a school year.
  4. The sixth column in the oral reading fluency chart shows the number of words a child, based on his percentile level, typically gains in his WCPM count each week.

By viewing the Oral Reading Fluency Chart, you can see the vast difference in oral reading fluency rates between the 90%ile child and the 10%ile child.  There is even a gigantic difference between the 50%ile child and the 10%ile child.  This evidence confirms the importance of incorporating fluency training into lesson plans with emergent and beginning readers.

 

TIMED REPEATED READING

What is a Timed Repeated Reading?

Timed Repeated Reading calculates your child’s reading rate of a book or passage over multiple readings.  The units used are words per minute (wpm).

Why should I do Timed Repeated Reading?

Timed Repeated Reading keeps track of your child’s fluency training progress.  It is important for your records as a parent tutor.  Timed repeated reading progress can be presented on a child-friendly chart.  It is motivating for your child to see that she is growing as a reader.

How do I do a Timed Repeated Reading?

Before your child starts the Timed Repeated Reading, count the words in the book or passage.  Have a stopwatch and calculator on hand.  Use the stopwatch to count how many seconds it takes your child to read the book.  Tally the number of miscues or errors your child makes while reading.  Calculate the number of correctly read words by subtracting the number of miscues from the number of words in the book.

Number of words in the book – Number of Miscues = Number of correctly read words

To calculate your child’s reading rate, multiply the number of correctly read words in the book times 60 and divide by the number of seconds it took your child to read the book.

(Number of correctly read words x 60 seconds) / number of seconds it took your child to read = reading rate in words per minute

Example: Book has 81 words, child made 2 miscues, and it took 135 seconds to read.

(79 words x 60 seconds) / 135 seconds = 35 words per minute (wpm)

How do I record a Timed Repeated Reading?

Use the TIMED REPEATED READING CHART to record reading rate progress for a specific book.  Each time your child reads a book, calculate the reading rate and document it on the Timed Repeated Reading Chart.  The Chart has space for 6 different readings of the same book.  Over the six readings, the reading rate should increase.  You and your child will be able to see the improvement on the chart.

You can add more information, if you like, to the Timed Repeated Reading Chart I attached.  You can include the book’s reading level next to the space for the title.  You may want to record the dates of each reading of the book.  It is possible that the range of the reading rate, 10wpm – 80 wpm, should be modified to more appropriately fit your child’s reading rate.

Here is an  EXAMPLE TIMED REPEATED READING CHART.  The book’s title is Nature Hike.  The book was read 6 times.  The reading rates for the six readings are, in order: 28 wpm, 31 wpm, 32 wpm, 38 wpm 36 wpm and 45 wpm.  The general trend is that the reading rate increased over the six readings.  You can see that the child’s reading rate was a bit slower on the fifth reading.  It is to be expected that the child will occasionally read more slowly than on a previous reading.

FLUENCY TRAINING

Fluency training is an EXTREMELY important part of the twice-weekly tutoring plan.

What is fluency training?

Reading fluency is developed with practice.  When a child is learning to read, it is important for him to reread easy books.  With each reading, he will become more familiar with the text and will be able to read more accurately and smoothly and with increased speed and better expression.

Why is fluency training important?

Fluency training builds confidence in the young reader.  He is able to hear himself read like proficient readers do.

What materials should I use for fluency training?

Use books/texts at your child’s independent reading level.  If you do not know your child’s independent reading level, read the post, How Can I Figure Out My Child’s Reading Level?

You may also use books at your child’s instructional reading level that he has already read.  Over multiple readings, the text will become increasingly familiar and your child will be able to read it with greater accuracy, ideally with a 98% accuracy rate or better.  (The link in previous paragraph to the post, How Can I Figure Out My Child’s Reading Level?, will also explain how to determine your child’s instructional reading level and his reading accuracy rate.)

Poetry can be incorporated into fluency training since its rhythm, rhyme and humor encourage children to read smoothly and with good phrasing and expression.  A few poetry compilations that I recommend are Here’s a Little Poem: A Very First Book of Poetry by Jane Yolen, Andrew Fusek Peters and Polly Dunbar, Read Aloud Rhymes for the Very Young by Jack Pretlusky and Marc Brown and Shout! Little Poems that Roar by Brod Bagert and Sachiko Yoshikawa.  I find that humorous and rhyming poems are easiest to read.  Poems with tongue-twisters, nonsense words and multi-syllabic words are difficult and frustrating for the young reader.

Your child should read books/texts between 4 and 6 times during the fluency training part of the lesson (spread out over many lessons) before retiring the book.

Have many books and poems on hand so that your child has some choice about the books he will read during fluency training.  He should read between 2 and 4 books during this part of the lesson.

As part of your documentation process and a fun visual for your child, keep track of how many times your child has read a specific book or poem.  Use stickers or stars to fill in the FLUENCY TRAINING BOOK TALLY CHART.

At what point during the lesson should I do fluency training?

Start every tutoring lesson with fluency training.  It is a confidence-boosting warm-up.

Reading 2 to 4 books or poems will take between 10 and 15 minutes.

What support should I provide during fluency training?

You should not have to provide much support during fluency training since the books your child is reading are easy for him.  He should consistently be reading with between 95% and 100% accuracy.  The accuracy should increase over the multiple readings.

If your child does not know a word and hesitates or makes an error, withhold support initially and see if he self-corrects.  If he asks for help, I recommend telling him the word.  Fluency training is not the instructional portion of the lesson, during which word attack strategies are taught.  Plus, by supplying the word, it is possible that the reading will remain smooth and relatively uninterrupted.

After the book is finished, if you would like to address a misread word, do it.  For an emergent reader, who mostly uses context and at best initial letters to figure out a word, try cuing in the following manner:

Original text: I can run.  Dog can run.  I can jump.  Dog can jump.  I can swim.  Dog can swim.

Read as: I can run.  Dog can run.  I can fly .  Dog can fly.  I can swim.  Dog can swim.

Parent cuing: (Open to page: I can jump.  Dog can jump.)  Please read this page again.

Child: I can flyDog can fly.

Parent: Look at this word (pointing to fly).  You read this word as fly, but look at the first letter in this word.  What is it?

Child: j

Parent: What sound does j make?

Child: /j/

Parent: That’s right!  Look at the picture.  What could the girl be doing that begins with the sound /j/?

Child: Jumping!

Parent: Great!  Now reread the page using the word that starts with a /j/, jump.

Child: I can jump.  Dog can jump.

For an explanation of the different stages of literacy development, including the emergent reader, read my post, Developmental Stages of Literacy.

If your child reads with less than 95% accuracy during fluency training, he is making too many miscues, or errors.  Pick an easier book.

It may seem that your emergent reader is simply memorizing the text and that he would not know the words from the book in isolation.  That is okay.  This is all part of the process of learning to read.  A child needs multiple exposures to a word before he truly learns it.  Rereading books 4 to 6 times will provide this level of exposure.

Further documentation during fluency training

Learn how to calculate your child’s reading rate (the speed at which he reads) during Timed Repeated Reading.  This documentation is not as important for the emergent reader because he reads so slowly, but I highly recommend using timed repeated reading and keeping tracking of your child’s reading rate when his reading skills improve and he can be classified as a beginning reader.  Consider using the TIMED REPEATED READING CHART once your child is reading books leveled F or higher.  There is no harm if you are interested in starting to calculate reading rate during timed repeated reading sooner.